The Milburn Review

By

,

An illustration with text that reads "The Milburn review. What does it mean for young disabled people and care leavers?" next to the title of the Independent report by the government called "from a welfare state to a working state: a new settlement for the next generation"

By Molly Deakin, Charity Policy and Campaigns Officer and DWP’s Independent Disability Advisory Panel member 

About the review 

Published on 17 November, the Milburn Review proposes changes to education, health services, employment support and benefits to help more young people into education, training and work. It aims to reduce the proportion of 16 to 24-year-olds who are not in education, employment or training (NEET) from around 13% to 5% by 2036. 

It is important to note that the government has not agreed to everything in the report. Current benefits will continue while ministers consider the recommendations. 

In August, I worked with the Milburn team to design and deliver accessible participation workshops for young disabled people in Birmingham, Newcastle and London. Alan Milburn wanted to understand their experiences of education, employment and training, and what was preventing them from taking part. We found that participants want to work and learn, but described barriers at almost every stage. Their difficulties were rarely about a lack of ambition or effort. 

We know this to be true at Together Trust, where many of the young people we support have ambitions to work, study and live independently, but face systems that make the transition into adulthood unnecessarily difficult.

Our report, What comes after education?, produced with National Star, found that 45% of young people did not have a plan for leaving education, while 80% of parents and carers did not know what was supposed to happen next. Three-quarters of parents and carers also reported that organisations were not working well together. Too often, young people are left without the planning, support or opportunities they need to move into adulthood with confidence. 

I brought the experiences and findings from the Milburn workshops together in a report for Alan Milburn to consider as part of his review. I’m pleased to see many of the barriers raised reflected in the final report, which recognises how much needs to change. Its proposals are ambitious and get a lot right, but delivering them will require government departments to work together to address the barriers young people described. Young people need access to the skills, practical support and opportunities that will allow them to pursue their ambitions. 

Proposed changes to the welfare system 

Headlines about scrapping Universal Credit Health Element and Personal Independence Payments (PIP) for under-25s have understandably caused alarm among disabled people. Milburn proposes replacing these benefits with new payments and services, although the review acknowledges that many would receive less cash support. The main proposals are: 

Creating a separate benefits system risks adding administrative complexity and further disruption to young people’s lives as they move between systems at 18 and 25. These arbitrary age cut-offs are difficult to justify when disabled people’s support needs do not necessarily change at those ages. This is particularly concerning for many disabled young people who may take longer to complete their education or enter employment. 

PIP already helps with the extra costs of disability whether someone is working or not. Reducing that support could make it harder to get into work or stay there. The government must explain who would lose out and by how much, and how linked support, including Carer’s Allowance and Motability, would be protected. Carers also need certainty about their household income. 

The review says replacement support should happen before any changes to benefits, with protection for existing PIP recipients relying on payments for established, ongoing costs in work or education. These proposed safeguards matter, and services must be accessible and working for the individual first. Reducing income while someone waits for treatment, adjustments, or suitable work would add to their barriers. Better services cannot be treated as proof that someone no longer needs financial help, including when they cannot work. 

Schools 

Disabled young people taking part in the workshops highlighted where school failed to set them up with skills required to move into adult life. This sentiment does seem to have been understood by Milburn, who calls for: 

Attendance and support for families 

At the Together Trust, we have been researching emotionally based school non-attendance (EBSNA), and we have heard how distressing and sometimes traumatic school can be, particularly where special educational needs and disabilities (SEND) go unsupported. We also heard from parent-carers who have reduced their hours, changed jobs or stopped working altogether to support a child unable to attend school. Many parents we spoke to at the Trust have also had to seek support privately. 

Persistent absence affects the whole family, including parents’ ability to work. Therefore, Milburn’s recognition of the causes and consequences of persistent and severe school absence is welcome. He calls for earlier support, trusted adults in schools and better coordination between education, health and local services. However, asking schools and agencies to do more simply is not enough. Families need clear routes to services, timely interventions and properly trained staff with the time and resources to help. Schools, local authorities and health services must be able to work together around the child. 

SEND and early intervention 

Milburn recognises that additional needs often become apparent long before support arrives. The review’s call for practical help without families having to fight through diagnostic or administrative barriers is welcome and overdue. However, Milburn explicitly endorses the government’s proposed SEND reforms and fails to call out where the current plans for reform will fall short of this; the government’s plans to narrow eligibility for future EHCPs risk weakening children’s enforceable rights. Similarly, plans to move more pupils into mainstream settings will require sufficient staffing, training and specialist resources to be in place first. Government cannot deliver the improvements Milburn calls for while weakening the protections and support children with SEND rely on. 

Understanding who needs support 

Milburn calls for information about attendance, health and support needs to be brought together and acted on before a young person becomes NEET. Persistent absence, exclusions and unmet SEND or mental health needs can reveal where education and transitions into adulthood are breaking down, but the current system does not consistently identify or respond to these warning signs.

Our EBSNA research found no data showing how many children were experiencing emotionally based school non-attendance. We agree that better information is needed to reveal unmet need, but collecting it must lead to timely, practical support when a child’s education begins to break down. 

Further and higher education 

The Milburn Review recognises that vocational education has become smaller and weaker, despite further education (FE) colleges supporting many of the young people most at risk of becoming NEET. It also acknowledges the difficulties young people face when transitioning from school at 16. Milburn calls for FE to become England’s main route for technical education and support through transitions, with universities placing greater emphasis on employability. Expanding further education and apprenticeships is identified as a priority for reducing the number of young people who are NEET. Milburn proposes: 

At Together Trust, we believe further education should be person-centred, preparing young people for work where possible and supporting their wider ambitions. We welcome the proposed investment in further education and the wider opportunities it could create. Young people should be able to study subjects that interest them, with the support they need to participate and progress. Government must ensure accessibility and inclusion are built into new provision from the outset, backed by sufficient resources for disabled young people to take part meaningfully. 

Apprenticeships 

Milburn makes apprenticeships his largest education and skills priority, proposing to: 

The review’s push for more practical routes into training and employment is welcome. Apprenticeships can give young people opportunities to succeed where traditional academic routes may not suit them. The government will need to ensure that recruitment, learning, work and transitions are inclusive and accessible to young disabled people and should ensure that support is readily available throughout for this to be successful. 

However, it is important to note that shifting funding away from older learners could disadvantage disabled people who take longer to complete their education or prepare for work. Government must recognise that people reach opportunities such as apprenticeships at different stages and allow flexibility in funding and eligibility, so that those entering employment later because of their needs or circumstances are not overlooked. 

Children in care and care leavers 

The review recognises the additional barriers and vulnerabilities care leavers can face when transitioning into adulthood, and the state’s responsibility to care-experienced young people. The review proposes a £50 weekly Care Leaver Transition Allowance for six months, for those NEET or at serious risk, provided they are on an agreed YOS participation plan and taking part in the agreed activities. We welcome this additional financial support and the recognition that care leavers need some of the security others receive from their families. 

The review also acknowledges that an allowance alone cannot overcome every barrier and calls for coordinated support with housing, health and education. However, the proposals do not go far enough in addressing the wider failures of the care system that leave young people poorly supported as they enter adulthood. Improving the support they receive both in care and when leaving may matter at least as much as changes to employment services. Young people should not be expected to manage independence before they have the practical help and trusted relationships they need. 

Care-experienced young people may also be dealing with the effects of trauma, abuse or neglect, alongside mental health needs and social isolation. While this short-term financial support is welcome, lasting improvements require safe, stable homes and consistent financial, practical and emotional support. Government must address these wider barriers, with specialist support and independent advocacy available as standard and shaped around each young person’s needs. 

Health and vocational support 

At the Milburn workshops, young disabled people described long waits for mental health support or diagnosis that disrupted education, training and work, with many reaching crisis before receiving help. Similarly, Together Trust parent-carers have shared similar experiences of their children becoming severely unwell and unable to participate due to a lack of access to appropriate interventions and services. 

The review proposes: 

We welcome these proposals, but faster access to community mental health services has been promised for years. Support must arrive before crisis and reflect individual needs. Digital services must not become a barrier to clinical care, requiring young people to complete unsuitable programmes before seeing a qualified professional. 

Additionally, although the review says care should remain based on need, the government must ensure prioritising those who are NEET does not lengthen waits or reduce support for those already working, including disabled young people and care leavers who need help to keep their jobs. 

Neurodivergence, ADHD and Autism 

At all three of the Milburn workshops, young people described specific barriers associated with ADHD or autism. Participants described inaccessible environments, the severe pressure to adhere to ‘social norms’, a lack of reasonable adjustments, and many feared disclosing diagnoses or requesting help because of discrimination and harmful narratives about overdiagnosis or avoiding work. The review recognises the importance of patient, flexible support from people who understand the individual.

Milburn proposes: 

These practical proposals offer a more constructive focus than much of the previous debate about disability and welfare. Help based on need could prevent difficulties from becoming entrenched while young people wait. We work with many young people who have gone through multiple failed provisions before they arrive at the Together Trust, and we know exactly how tailored, specialised support can transform a neurodivergent student’s education experience and outcomes. 

Getting into and staying in work 

Participants at the Milburn workshops described job searching as demoralising and exhausting. Long applications, rigid criteria, AI tools and psychometric tests created barriers to getting a job, with some participants having applied for tens or hundreds of jobs. 

One workshop participant had not achieved their expected GCSE grades due to experiencing ill health, but went on to achieve a first-class degree in a science subject. Despite this, they were rejected from a job due to their GCSE results. These experiences highlight the desperate need for a system which is more flexible and accounts for the complexity of being disabled, rather than rigid pathways and structures which don’t account for the barriers young people may face.

One participant said, “Every single time I have opened up, it has been a negative experience.”

Repeated rejection and stigmatising experiences affect whether someone feels able to try again. 

Milburn proposes: 

Improving the youth labour market 

The review places considerable emphasis on employers creating more opportunities for young people, including disabled young people and care leavers. Financial incentives that encourage employers to hire young people could help more young people to get into work. Lower employer National Insurance contributions for workers aged 21 to 24 could also help. However, this would initially apply only to retail and hospitality, and only “when fiscal conditions allow”, leaving uncertainty about when, or whether, the change would happen. 

The IFS also warns that targeted incentives and funding shifts could come at the expense of other young people and older workers. This matters particularly for disabled people who enter employment later, including those who spend longer completing their education. Someone seeking their first job at 25 could face the same barriers as a younger applicant while falling outside the age criteria for hiring incentives. Government must account for these different routes into work and assess whether the review’s proposals create more opportunities overall or mainly just change who gets them. 

Inclusive work environments 

However, getting someone into work is only part of the challenge; many of the Milburn workshop participants described inaccessible work environments, a lack of reasonable adjustments, discrimination or an inability to progress. Employers must also be able to support them to stay there, with accessible workplaces, reasonable adjustments, flexible working arrangements and appropriate support. Milburn recognises that employers are increasingly supporting young people with complex health needs, low confidence and limited workplace experience, while smaller businesses often lack the resources or specialist knowledge to provide this support.

The review proposes clearer guidance on reasonable adjustments and access to advice through the Youth Opportunity Service and Acas, helping employers and young people resolve problems before employment breaks down. These proposals are welcome, but improving opportunities for disabled young people requires a wider shift in how workplaces operate. Employers must understand and uphold their responsibilities, but they also need the training, resources and practical support to do so. Creating more jobs will achieve little if workplaces remain inaccessible or young people cannot get the support they need to stay in them. 

Access to Work 

The government should work to improve existing structures before they are put under more pressure. For example, Access to Work should already help with equipment and support needed for employment. Workshop participants also described long waits for Access to Work and staff who were unsure what could help or did not explain the options, leaving them to work this out themselves. One participant described receiving their Access to Work support after they had already left their job.

Additionally, disabled people and specialist organisations have also reported reductions in support-worker funding and restrictions on routine email contact with caseworkers. Email remains available as a reasonable adjustment, but evidence submitted to Parliament suggests this is not always explained or provided consistently. Reducing delays, improving advice and continuity, and offering accessible communication are essential to making work possible and sustainable. 

Final thoughts 

Having helped deliver the Milburn workshops, I’m encouraged to see young disabled people’s experiences reflected in the report. At its strongest, it recognises that helping them get into and stay in work requires structural changes across education, healthcare, social care, welfare and employment. That recognition is welcome, but turning the review’s ambitions into meaningful change will require coordinated action across government, with different departments working together to address the barriers young people face. 

I support Milburn’s call to invest in better support and systems, with the potential for longer-term savings. Government must now work across departments and alongside care leavers, disabled young people, disabled people’s organisations and charities to shape, deliver and assess the changes. Their involvement must influence what happens next. 

Young disabled people and care leavers need to see a difference in their everyday lives: support that arrives when they need it, financial security and opportunities they can actually take up. They have ambitions for their futures; it’s now the government’s job to make sure they have what they need to be able to pursue them. 

Molly Deakin is Together Trust’s Charity Policy and Campaigns Officer and a member of the DWP’s Independent Disability Advisory Panel. She brings her lived experience as a disabled person, alongside the perspectives of other disabled people and Together Trust’s service users, to the panel’s work. Through this role, Molly helped the Milburn Review team design and deliver workshops with young disabled people to understand the barriers they face in accessing and staying in education, employment and training. 

Stay up to date with our policy and campaigns work   

Share me